Teething toys are a lifesaver when your little one is suffering from the pain of cutting teeth. But you want to ensure that you find safe and comfortable toys for your baby to chew on to ease their pain and not make it worse.
Some teething toys are not soft enough or have rigid parts that can hurt and frustrate your baby. And some are poorly designed and don’t reach those painful spots. You also want to ensure that your teething toys are not laden with harmful chemicals or BPA.
We’ve tested all the top brands to find the ten best teething toys for your little one. These teethers are both parent and baby approved and are sure to turn your baby’s cries into gummy smiles.
- Dishwasher safe
- Babies can hold them easily
- Non-toxic, phthalate-free, BPA-free
- Inexpensive
- Made entirely of soft, chewy silicone
- Comes with a case
- Multifarious textures
- Passed all safety testing certification
- Massages baby’s gums
- Smooth, round edges
- Heavy-duty teether
- Perfect for baby's grip
- Soft cuddly body
- Multiple textures
- Eye-catching bright colors
- FDA approved
- Affordable and non-toxic
- Freezer and dishwasher safe
- All-natural materials
- Cute design
- Soft for cuddling
- Award-winning grasping toy
- Non-toxic & water based
- Attractive bright colors
- Affordable
- Can be refrigerated
- Different textures
- Keeps baby entertained
- Wide variety of shapes to choose
- Comes with 9 toys
Review Methodology: At Mom Loves Best, our thorough analysis and research on teething toys involve hands-on experience and assessment of numerous products to provide you with reliable results and recommendations. We evaluate each toy based on key factors such as safety, materials, design, and effectiveness in soothing teething discomfort. Our criteria for ranking teething toys are based on performance, user experience, and expert reviews. By comparing various toys, we identify unique features that set them apart from competitors. Drawing upon our professional expertise, we highlight the top ten teething toys, considering important aspects like durability, ease of use, and baby’s preferences. Trust our findings, as we aim to make the decision-making process easier for you, ensuring your little one gets the best teething toy for their needs.
The Best Teething Toys of 2024
Here are the top teething toys on the market.
Bonbino Teether Rings 4-Pack
Best Teething Rings
Moms who like traditional teething rings should approve of this four-pack set. These teethers are non-toxic, phthalate-free, BPA-free, and they come in four bright colors.
Each silicone ring has several different textures so your baby can find a spot that feels good on their aching gums.
The ring shape, along with the texture, will help your baby get a firm grip. You can also slide them onto your wrist or your baby’s wrist so you always have one on hand (no pun intended).
Pros
- They’re dishwasher safe for easy sanitizing.
- Babies can hold onto them easily.
- It comes with an e-book of remedies to help your baby with teething.
Cons
- They may be too large to reach a small baby’s back teeth.
- Costly for four simple rings.
Our Ratings
User Experience
Nuby Silicone Teethe-eez Teething Toy
Best Silicone Teething Toy
This teether is made entirely of soft, chewy silicone. One end has flexible bristles that can help soothe your baby’s sore gums. It also has different textured surfaces on the handle and the end of the teether so your baby can chew on either side of it.
It comes with a carrying case so you can keep it clean when it’s not in use, making it easy to take it along in the diaper bag on trips.
Pros
- It’s inexpensive.
- The small ring attached makes it easy for babies to grab onto.
- It comes with a case so it won’t get dirty when not in use.
Cons
- If you have pets, their hair will stick to it like crazy.
- It’s a bit big for babies who are cutting their first teeth.
Our Ratings
Personal Perspective
Baby Elefun Teethers Teething Toy
Best for Early Teethers (3-4 Months Old)
To entice your child into wanting to try these, they made it easy to hold and apetizing to look with its colorful hues.
That’s why they’re perfect for babies who are 3 and 4 months old, who are at that point where they’re very interested in food. This helps develop fine motor and hand-eye coordination skills while at the same time helps soothe their gums.
Pros
- Multifarious textures so your child won’t get bored.
- Passed all safety testing certification.
- The teether has a textured surface to massage your baby’s gums.
Cons
- Wear and tear may be noticed.
- Limited design.
Our Ratings
Community Feedback
Sili Chews Cell Phone Toddler Teething Toy
Best Teething Toy for Toddlers
Toddlers can be like teenagers — they both love to get their hands on a phone. Since this teething toy is made to look like a cell phone, toddlers will want to check it out. With a phone of their own, maybe they won’t be as interested in yours.
This teether is also easy to clean — you just have to rinse it off.
The smooth, rounded edges won’t be too sharp for your baby’s mouth, and the phone is big enough that it’ll fit well in your baby’s hands.
Pros
- It’s easy for toddlers to hold.
- The phone has ridges on it, so they can chew on the part that feels most comfortable.
- It may be enough to get your toddler to leave your phone alone.
Cons
- It’s a bit pricey.
- The simple design may not keep your toddler occupied for long.
Our Ratings
First-Hand Impression
Lamaze Sprinkles The Jellyfish Teething Toy
Best Teething Toy Animals
This is an adorable product that offers a lot more than just teething relief. It doubles as a cuddly, comforting toy that can go everywhere with your little one.
The tentacles on the jellyfish are soft teethers your baby should have fun chewing on, and its face will crinkle every time your baby grabs them.
When your baby shakes the toy, it creates a delightful sound. The jellyfish also has a clip that will keep it attached to your baby’s stroller or diaper bag so it doesn’t get dropped.
Pros
- Soft, cuddly toy.
- Multiple textures to keep your baby interested.
- It has eye-catching bright colors.
Cons
- Others thought that design and features could be improved.
- Runs a bit small.
Our Ratings
User Experience
Tinabless 5-Pack Teething Toys
Best Freezable Teething Toy
You can stash this pack of five fruit-shaped teething toys in the freezer so your baby will feel the soothing chill whenever they chew on them.
Concerned about safety? These are FDA approved and made of food-grade silicone, plus they’re free of phthalates, latex, BPA, lead, and PVC.
The fruit toys have various textures, so your baby will get a different sensation with each one. The handles also have a no-slip grip, making them easy to hang onto, even when they’re covered in drool.
Pros
- The various textures offer different sensations on your baby’s gums.
- They are affordable, considering you get four in the package.
- They’re safe in the freezer as well as the dishwasher.
Cons
- The handles are very thin, making them tricky for younger children to hold.
Our Ratings
Organic Farm Buddies Teething Rattle
Best Natural Teething Toy (Organic)
This charming rattle is made of 100 percent organic cotton, so you don’t have to worry about your baby really tucking into it.
It also uses sustainable corn fiber filler, which is natural and hypoallergenic. These toys are safe for any age, and moms concerned about unnatural substances in their baby’s toys will like that these are good for babies and good for the environment.
This cuddly toy can be used for comfort as well as pain relief.
Pros
- Made of all-natural materials.
- Cute-looking design comes in different animal characters like fox, cow, or flamingo.
- It’s soft for cuddling.
Cons
- The rattle part is pretty quiet.
- The handle is fairly big, making it difficult for a younger baby to grasp.
- It doesn’t hold up very well in the wash.
Our Ratings
Community Feedback
Manhattan Toy Wooden Beads Teether
Best Wooden Teething Toy
These giant wooden beads are connected by elastic. Their bright colors make them visually appealing to babies and toddlers. And the non-toxic, water-based color doesn’t pose any threat to your child.
The wood won’t splinter or chip, and when your baby pulls on the beads or twist them around, they make a fun clanking noise.
Pros
- These are big enough your baby wouldn’t choke if the elastic breaks.
- Made without toxic chemicals.
- The bright colors are attractive for babies.
Cons
- It’s pretty heavy for younger babies.
- The heavier design can be painful if babies accidentally hit themselves with the toy.
Our Ratings
First-Hand Impression
Nuby IcyBite Keys Teething Toy
Best Nuby Teething Toy
These cute keys come in bright colors and are all attached to a ring. There’s a variety of different surfaces your baby will love gnashing on. The softer parts feel great when their gums are tender, but when they’re trying to do the difficult work of cutting a tooth, they may go for the harder parts.
Your baby will be able to reach all their teeth due to the shape of the keys, and the ring is easy for young babies to hold.
You can stick this in the refrigerator for a while to give your baby an extra cooling effect.
Pros
- They’re affordable, so you can purchase one set for home and another for the diaper bag.
- Can be refrigerated.
- The different textures will feel nice on your baby’s gums.
Cons
- It’s possible for the teether to be punctured and leak fluid.
- Because of all the nooks and crannies, the keys can be hard to clean thoroughly.
Our Ratings
User Experience
WishTime Rattle Teething Toy Set
Best Teething Toy Set
This fantastic set comes with nine teethers and rattles for your baby to enjoy. The variety of colors will help attract your baby’s attention.
The ABS plastic is non-toxic and BPA-free. The set also comes in a cute baby bottle carrying case, so when your baby gets a little older, they can have fun putting the toys in the case and dumping them out again.
The case also makes this set portable, so it’s great to take with you on vacation or to a babysitter’s house.
Pros
- Some of the toys make noise, which will keep your baby entertained.
- A wide variety of shapes to choose from.
- You’ll get a lot of toys for the price.
Cons
- The edges are a little rough.
- Some parents may find the horn toy’s noise to be loud.
Personal Perspective
When Should I Give My Baby Teething Toys?
Most babies will get their first tooth when they’re 4 to 6 months old (1), but teething pain can start weeks before that.
Take Note
How to Choose Teething Toys for Baby
With such a wide variety of teething toys available, you need to put some thought into what you want or you’ll be overwhelmed. Here are some factors to consider to help you narrow your search.
Material
Some moms can feel their blood pressure going up just thinking about their baby chewing on a plastic teether. They worry about the harmful chemicals their baby may be ingesting. If plastic isn’t to your liking, there are other options, like wood or silicone.
Fillings
Some products are filled with a soothing gel-like material, and you can refrigerate them to keep cool, which feels great on your baby’s gums. But if you’re anxious about your baby potentially poking a hole in the teether and possibly ingesting some of that gel, you may want to skip this type.
Clips
Babies are not known to hang on to their toys for long. And teethers are one of those items you don’t want to get dirty on the floor. One way to solve this problem is by getting a teething toy that clips onto their outfit.
Easy-grip
Babies seem to have the best grip on products that have a ring to hold. And some are made with extra textures to aid that grip. This prevents you from constantly having to pick up and clean dropped toys and makes it easier for babies to use the teether, especially in a vehicle where you may not be able to help them.
Noisiness
Some products make a squeaky noise when babies bite on them. That may make your baby smile, but it can annoy you after a while. When your baby isn’t crying, you may wish for nothing but silence in your house. If that sounds like you, you’ll want to skip things that squeak.
Size
Since babies love to put everything in their mouths, they’re at increased risk of choking. Because their airways are so small, it doesn’t take much to block them. The best teething toys will be large enough that your child can’t stick them entirely in their mouth and choke.
Teething Toy FAQs
Can Teething Toys Damage Teeth?
When used appropriately, teething toys shouldn’t damage your baby’s teeth. Always pick toys designed for teething that is safe, non-toxic, and free from small parts that could be a choking hazard. And check the toys for wear and replace them if they become damaged.
How Many Teething Toys Do Babies Need?
The number of teething toys your baby needs depends on their personal preference and how easily they bore things. Having 2-3 different types of teething toys available can provide variety and ensure there’s always a clean one ready to use.
Do You Freeze or Refrigerate Teething Toys?
While some teething toys can be cooled in the refrigerator to provide additional relief to a teething baby, it’s generally not recommended to freeze them as they can become too hard and potentially harm your baby’s gums. Always follow the manufacturer’s instructions.
Is the Gel Inside Teething Rings Toxic?
Most modern teething toys are made with safety standards in mind, and the gel inside teething rings is usually non-toxic. But if a teething ring breaks and the gel leaks, it’s best to get rid of the toy immediately to avoid any potential risk.
When Should You Remove Teething Toys?
You should remove and replace teething toys if they show signs of wear and tear, like cracks or leaks, to prevent them from becoming a choking hazard. As your child ages and their teeth develop, they might also outgrow the need for teething toys.
What Are the Safest Teething Toys for Babies?
The safest teething toys are those that are made from non-toxic, BPA-free materials and do not have small parts that could pose a choking hazard.
Some safe and popular brands include Nuby and Manhattan Toy. Always check the safety standards and age recommendations before giving a teething toy to your baby.
The Bottom Line
The 4-pack of teether rings is our top pick as the best teething toy. They’re simple, but we like that about them. They are everything we want in a teether — easy to hold, easy to chew on, non-toxic, and they have a variety of textures.
We also like that they aren’t filled with any liquid or gel that can eventually leak, and you can pop them in the dishwasher for easy cleaning.
